# ShopCall.ai - Missing Features & Incomplete Implementation Report

**Generated:** 2025-10-22
**Project:** ShopCall.ai (AI-powered calling system for e-commerce)
**Repositories:**
- Frontend: `shopcall.ai-main` (React/Vite/TypeScript)
- Backend: `shopcall.ai-backend-main` (Express.js/Node.js)

---

## 🔴 **CRITICAL MISSING FEATURES**

### 1. **Onboarding Flow - Not Connected to Backend**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/OnboardingContent.tsx`

**Status:** UI complete, backend integration missing

**Issues:**
- ❌ No API integration for submitting onboarding data
- ❌ Shopify connection flow exists in UI but doesn't save to backend
- ❌ Phone number selection doesn't persist
- ❌ Package selection doesn't create subscription
- ❌ `handleFinish()` function only redirects to homepage (line 100-108)

**Missing Backend Endpoints:**
```
POST /api/onboarding/complete
  Body: {
    shopifyUrl: string,
    selectedPhone: string,
    selectedPackage: string
  }
```

**Impact:** Users can complete onboarding but nothing is saved. On next login, they'll need to onboard again.

**Effort:** Medium (2-3 days)

---

### 2. **Shopify OAuth Integration Incomplete**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-backend-main/api/index.js:532-597`

**Status:** OAuth flow works, but tokens not persisted

**Issues:**
- ✅ OAuth authorization flow implemented
- ✅ Token exchange working
- ❌ **TODO Comment (line 586):** "Save tokenJson.access_token securely" - tokens not being stored
- ❌ No store record created in `stores` table after successful OAuth
- ❌ Redirect goes to homepage (`https://shopcall.ai/`) instead of dashboard
- ❌ User-to-store relationship not established

**Current Code:**
```javascript
// Line 586
// TODO: Save tokenJson.access_token securely
console.log(`Successfully authenticated shop: ${normalizedShop}`);

res.redirect(`https://shopcall.ai/`);
```

**Required Fix:**
```javascript
// Save to database
const { data: storeData, error: storeError } = await supabase
  .from('stores')
  .insert({
    user_id: nonceData.userId, // from nonce
    platform_name: 'shopify',
    store_name: normalizedShop.split('.')[0],
    store_url: `https://${normalizedShop}`,
    access_token: tokenJson.access_token,
    scopes: tokenJson.scope.split(','),
    connected_at: new Date().toISOString()
  });

res.redirect(`https://shopcall.ai/dashboard?connected=true`);
```

**Impact:** Shopify stores cannot be properly connected. OAuth succeeds but connection is lost immediately.

**Effort:** Small (1 day)

---

### 3. **Phone Number Management - UI Only**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/PhoneNumbersContent.tsx`

**Status:** Complete UI mockup with static data

**Issues:**
- ❌ All data is hardcoded in `connectedShops`, `availableCountries`, `carriers` arrays
- ❌ No backend API for phone number operations
- ❌ "Get Number" button (line 278) - no handler
- ❌ "Assign" button (line 196-199) - no handler
- ❌ "Connect" carrier buttons (line 231-234) - no handler
- ❌ Cannot actually purchase or assign phone numbers

**Missing Backend Endpoints:**
```
GET    /api/phone-numbers              # List phone numbers for user
POST   /api/phone-numbers              # Purchase new phone number
PUT    /api/phone-numbers/:id/assign   # Assign number to store
DELETE /api/phone-numbers/:id          # Release phone number

POST   /api/carriers/connect            # Connect external carrier (Twilio, etc.)
GET    /api/carriers                    # List connected carriers
```

**Missing Database Tables:**
```sql
CREATE TABLE phone_numbers (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY DEFAULT gen_random_uuid(),
  user_id UUID REFERENCES profiles(id),
  store_id UUID REFERENCES stores(id),
  number VARCHAR(20) NOT NULL,
  country VARCHAR(2) NOT NULL,
  type VARCHAR(20), -- 'local', 'toll-free'
  carrier VARCHAR(50), -- 'internal', 'twilio', 'telnyx', etc.
  status VARCHAR(20), -- 'active', 'pending_kyc', 'inactive'
  monthly_cost DECIMAL(10,2),
  carrier_config JSONB, -- carrier-specific data
  created_at TIMESTAMP DEFAULT NOW(),
  assigned_at TIMESTAMP
);

CREATE TABLE carrier_integrations (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY DEFAULT gen_random_uuid(),
  user_id UUID REFERENCES profiles(id),
  carrier_name VARCHAR(50), -- 'twilio', 'telnyx', 'vonage', 'zadarma'
  credentials JSONB, -- encrypted API keys
  is_active BOOLEAN DEFAULT true,
  created_at TIMESTAMP DEFAULT NOW()
);
```

**Impact:** Core feature completely non-functional. Users cannot set up phone numbers which are essential for the service to work.

**Effort:** Large (5-7 days including carrier API integrations)

---

### 4. **AI Configuration - UI Only**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/AIConfigContent.tsx`

**Status:** Complete UI for AI settings, no backend persistence

**Issues:**
- ❌ All settings stored only in component state
- ❌ "Save Configuration" button (line 55) - no handler
- ❌ "Sync Store Data" button (line 247) - no handler
- ❌ "Test Configuration" button (line 253) - no handler
- ❌ "Copy from Another Shop" button (line 52) - no handler
- ❌ Voice settings, greeting messages, escalation policy, knowledge base - none saved

**Missing Backend Endpoints:**
```
GET  /api/ai-config/:storeId           # Get AI config for store
POST /api/ai-config/:storeId           # Create/update AI config
POST /api/ai-config/:storeId/test      # Test AI configuration
POST /api/ai-config/:storeId/sync      # Sync store data (products, policies)
POST /api/ai-config/:storeId/copy      # Copy config from another store
```

**Missing Database Table:**
```sql
CREATE TABLE ai_configurations (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY DEFAULT gen_random_uuid(),
  store_id UUID REFERENCES stores(id) UNIQUE,

  -- Voice settings
  voice_type VARCHAR(50) DEFAULT 'sarah',
  speaking_speed VARCHAR(20) DEFAULT 'normal',
  accent VARCHAR(50) DEFAULT 'us-english',

  -- Conversation behavior
  greeting_message TEXT,
  business_hours_mode BOOLEAN DEFAULT true,
  local_currency_support BOOLEAN DEFAULT true,
  escalation_policy VARCHAR(20) DEFAULT 'medium',

  -- Knowledge base
  product_catalog_synced BOOLEAN DEFAULT false,
  product_catalog_last_sync TIMESTAMP,
  store_policies TEXT,
  faq_database JSONB,
  custom_knowledge JSONB,

  created_at TIMESTAMP DEFAULT NOW(),
  updated_at TIMESTAMP DEFAULT NOW()
);
```

**Impact:** AI cannot be customized per webshop. All stores would use default settings, making the service less valuable.

**Effort:** Medium-Large (4-5 days)

---

## 🟡 **HIGH PRIORITY MISSING FEATURES**

### 5. **Analytics Data - All Mocked**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/AnalyticsContent.tsx`

**Status:** Complete UI with charts, all using static data

**Issues:**
- ❌ `weeklyData`, `resolutionData`, `callDurationData`, `topIntentsData`, etc. - all hardcoded (lines 6-58)
- ❌ Charts display fake data
- ❌ No real metrics calculation
- ❌ Peak hours heatmap generated randomly (line 130)

**Missing Backend Endpoints:**
```
GET /api/analytics/overview?timeRange=week       # KPIs and overview charts
GET /api/analytics/trends?timeRange=month        # Trend analysis
GET /api/analytics/performance?timeRange=week    # Performance metrics
GET /api/analytics/call-volume?groupBy=day       # Call volume data
GET /api/analytics/intents?limit=10              # Top call intents
```

**Required Aggregation Logic:**
- Call volume by day/hour/week
- Resolution rate calculation
- Average call duration by intent
- Peak hours analysis
- Sentiment distribution
- Cost analysis

**Impact:** Dashboard shows misleading fake data. Users cannot make data-driven decisions.

**Effort:** Medium (3-4 days for proper aggregation queries)

---

### 6. **Dashboard KPIs - Hardcoded**

**Location:**
- `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/KPICards.tsx`
- `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/ChartsSection.tsx`
- `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/RecentCallsTable.tsx`

**Status:** Complete UI, static mock data

**Issues:**
- ❌ All KPI values hardcoded
- ❌ Charts show static data
- ❌ Recent calls table shows hardcoded 5 calls (lines 8-64 in RecentCallsTable.tsx)
- ❌ No refresh functionality

**Missing Backend Endpoint:**
```
GET /api/dashboard/summary?timeRange=24h
  Response: {
    totalCalls: number,
    resolvedCalls: number,
    activeConversations: number,
    avgResponseTime: number,
    resolutionRate: number,
    avgCallDuration: number,
    totalCost: number,
    chartData: {
      callVolume: [...],
      resolutionRate: [...]
    },
    recentCalls: [...]
  }
```

**Impact:** Dashboard is just a demo, not showing real data.

**Effort:** Small-Medium (2-3 days, reuses analytics logic)

---

### 7. **Webshop Integration Management - Partially Implemented**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/IntegrationsContent.tsx`

**Status:** Backend APIs exist, frontend not connected

**Issues:**
- ✅ Backend has `GET /api/stores` (line 800)
- ✅ Backend has `PUT /api/stores/:id` (line 855)
- ✅ Backend has `DELETE /api/stores/:id` (line 893)
- ❌ Frontend shows hardcoded `connectedShops` array (lines 10-86)
- ❌ "Connect Webshop" button (line 96-99) doesn't trigger OAuth
- ❌ Settings buttons (line 202) don't open edit modal
- ❌ No fetch call to `/api/stores`

**Required Frontend Changes:**
```typescript
const [stores, setStores] = useState([]);

useEffect(() => {
  const fetchStores = async () => {
    const response = await fetch('https://shopcall-ai-backend.vercel.app/api/stores', {
      headers: { 'Authorization': `Bearer ${token}` }
    });
    const data = await response.json();
    setStores(data.stores);
  };
  fetchStores();
}, []);
```

**Impact:** Users see fake store list instead of their actual connected stores.

**Effort:** Small (1 day to connect frontend to existing backend)

---

### 8. **Call Recording Playback**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/CallDetailsModal.tsx`

**Status:** UI exists, no audio implementation

**Issues:**
- ❌ Play button exists (line 145-152) but no audio player
- ❌ `recording_url` field in `call_logs` table not used
- ❌ No audio streaming functionality
- ❌ No waveform visualization
- ❌ Progress bar not functional (line 159-161)

**Required Implementation:**
```typescript
const [audio] = useState(new Audio());
const [isPlaying, setIsPlaying] = useState(false);
const [currentTime, setCurrentTime] = useState(0);
const [duration, setDuration] = useState(0);

useEffect(() => {
  if (call.recording_url) {
    audio.src = call.recording_url;
    audio.addEventListener('loadedmetadata', () => {
      setDuration(audio.duration);
    });
    audio.addEventListener('timeupdate', () => {
      setCurrentTime(audio.currentTime);
    });
  }
}, [call.recording_url]);

const handlePlayPause = () => {
  if (isPlaying) {
    audio.pause();
  } else {
    audio.play();
  }
  setIsPlaying(!isPlaying);
};
```

**Impact:** Cannot review call recordings, limiting quality assurance capabilities.

**Effort:** Small (1-2 days)

---

### 9. **WooCommerce Integration - Incomplete**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-backend-main/api/index.js:463-529`

**Status:** OAuth callback implemented, token storage works

**Issues:**
- ✅ OAuth initiation works (line 463)
- ✅ Callback saves credentials (line 481)
- ❌ No frontend UI to trigger WooCommerce connection
- ❌ No WooCommerce-specific configuration options
- ❌ Product sync not implemented
- ❌ No webhook setup for order updates

**Missing Features:**
- WooCommerce product catalog sync
- Order status webhooks
- Customer data integration
- Store policy import

**Impact:** WooCommerce support advertised but not fully functional.

**Effort:** Medium (3-4 days for full WooCommerce integration)

---

## 🟢 **MEDIUM PRIORITY MISSING FEATURES**

### 10. **Search & Filtering**

**Location:** Multiple components

**Issues:**
- ❌ Call logs search input exists but no filter logic (`CallLogsContent.tsx:118-124`)
- ❌ "Filters" button exists but no filter panel (`CallLogsContent.tsx:126-129`)
- ❌ Date range picker button non-functional (`CallLogsContent.tsx:107-111`)
- ❌ No backend support for query parameters

**Required Backend Changes:**
```
GET /api/call-logs?search=xxx&status=completed&outcome=resolved&dateFrom=...&dateTo=...
```

**Required Frontend Changes:**
- Search debouncing
- Filter panel UI
- Date range picker integration
- Query string management

**Impact:** Users must manually scroll through all calls, poor UX for high-volume users.

**Effort:** Small-Medium (2-3 days)

---

### 11. **Export Functionality**

**Location:** `shopcall.ai-main/src/components/CallLogsContent.tsx:102-105`

**Status:** Button exists, no implementation

**Issues:**
- ❌ Export button present but no click handler
- ❌ No backend endpoint for data export
- ❌ No file format options (CSV, PDF, Excel)

**Missing Backend Endpoint:**
```
GET /api/call-logs/export?format=csv&dateFrom=...&dateTo=...
  Response: CSV/PDF file download
```

**Required Features:**
- CSV export (for Excel)
- PDF export (formatted report)
- Email export option
- Export scheduling (weekly/monthly reports)

**Impact:** Users cannot extract data for external analysis or reporting.

**Effort:** Small (1-2 days)

---

### 12. **Real-time Updates**

**Status:** Not implemented

**Issues:**
- ❌ No WebSocket connection for live updates
- ❌ Dashboard requires manual refresh
- ❌ No notification system for new calls
- ❌ Active call status not real-time

**Required Implementation:**
- WebSocket server (Socket.io or native WebSockets)
- Real-time call status updates
- Live dashboard KPI updates
- Browser notifications

**Missing Infrastructure:**
```javascript
// Backend
const io = require('socket.io')(server);

io.on('connection', (socket) => {
  socket.on('authenticate', async (token) => {
    // Validate token and join user room
    socket.join(`user_${userId}`);
  });
});

// Emit on new call
io.to(`user_${userId}`).emit('new_call', callData);
```

**Impact:** Users miss real-time updates, dashboard feels outdated.

**Effort:** Medium (3-4 days for WebSocket implementation)

---

### 13. **User Profile Management**

**Status:** Not implemented

**Issues:**
- ❌ No profile page/route
- ❌ Cannot edit profile information (name, company, email)
- ❌ No password change functionality
- ❌ No account deletion option
- ❌ `profiles` table exists but no edit endpoint

**Missing Endpoints:**
```
GET    /api/profile                    # Get current user profile
PUT    /api/profile                    # Update profile
POST   /api/profile/change-password    # Change password
DELETE /api/profile                    # Delete account
```

**Missing Frontend Pages:**
- `/settings/profile` - Profile edit page
- `/settings/security` - Password change
- `/settings/account` - Account management

**Impact:** Users stuck with initial registration data. Cannot fix typos or update information.

**Effort:** Small-Medium (2-3 days)

---

### 14. **Payment Integration**

**Location:** `OnboardingContent.tsx:31-80` - Package selection UI

**Status:** Package selection UI only

**Issues:**
- ❌ No payment gateway integration (Stripe, PayPal, etc.)
- ❌ Package selection doesn't create subscription
- ❌ No billing page
- ❌ No invoice generation
- ❌ No payment history
- ❌ Free trial not tracked

**Missing Implementation:**
- Stripe/PayPal SDK integration
- Subscription management
- Webhook handling for payment events
- Billing portal

**Missing Endpoints:**
```
POST   /api/subscriptions/create        # Create subscription
GET    /api/subscriptions/current       # Get current subscription
POST   /api/subscriptions/cancel        # Cancel subscription
POST   /api/subscriptions/upgrade       # Upgrade plan
GET    /api/invoices                    # List invoices
```

**Missing Database Table:**
```sql
CREATE TABLE subscriptions (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY,
  user_id UUID REFERENCES profiles(id),
  plan_id VARCHAR(50), -- 'free-trial', 'starter', 'professional'
  status VARCHAR(20), -- 'active', 'cancelled', 'past_due'
  stripe_subscription_id VARCHAR(100),
  current_period_start TIMESTAMP,
  current_period_end TIMESTAMP,
  cancel_at_period_end BOOLEAN,
  created_at TIMESTAMP DEFAULT NOW()
);
```

**Impact:** Cannot monetize the service. All users have unlimited access.

**Effort:** Large (5-7 days for full payment integration)

---

### 15. **Email Notifications**

**Status:** Only OTP emails implemented

**Issues:**
- ✅ OTP email works (`sendOTPEmail` function exists)
- ❌ No call summary emails
- ❌ No alerts for failed calls
- ❌ No weekly/monthly reports
- ❌ No password reset emails
- ❌ No subscription notifications

**Missing Email Templates:**
- Call completed summary
- Failed call alert
- Weekly activity report
- Monthly invoice
- Password reset
- Subscription renewal reminder

**Required Implementation:**
- Email template system (Handlebars, Pug, etc.)
- Email queue (Bull, BullMQ)
- Background job processing
- Email service (SendGrid, Mailgun, or continue with Nodemailer)

**Impact:** Users not notified of important events. Must check dashboard constantly.

**Effort:** Medium (3-4 days)

---

## 🔵 **LOW PRIORITY / NICE TO HAVE**

### 16. **Advanced Call Features**

**Missing Features:**
- ❌ Call forwarding to human agents (escalation)
- ❌ Voicemail functionality
- ❌ Call scheduling (schedule calls for later)
- ❌ SMS fallback (if call fails, send SMS)
- ❌ Call recording consent management (GDPR)
- ❌ IVR (Interactive Voice Response) menu
- ❌ Call queuing
- ❌ After-hours handling

**Impact:** Basic AI calling only. Limited flexibility.

**Effort:** Large (ongoing feature development)

---

### 17. **Team Collaboration**

**Status:** Not implemented (single-user only)

**Missing Features:**
- ❌ Multi-user accounts (team members)
- ❌ Roles & permissions (admin, agent, viewer)
- ❌ Team member invitation
- ❌ Shared call notes/comments
- ❌ Call assignment to team members
- ❌ Activity logs

**Required Database Tables:**
```sql
CREATE TABLE team_members (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY,
  organization_id UUID,
  user_id UUID REFERENCES profiles(id),
  role VARCHAR(20), -- 'owner', 'admin', 'agent', 'viewer'
  permissions JSONB,
  invited_by UUID,
  invited_at TIMESTAMP,
  joined_at TIMESTAMP
);

CREATE TABLE organizations (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY,
  name VARCHAR(255),
  owner_id UUID REFERENCES profiles(id),
  created_at TIMESTAMP
);
```

**Impact:** Only suitable for solo users. Cannot scale to businesses with teams.

**Effort:** Large (7-10 days)

---

### 18. **API Documentation**

**Status:** Not implemented

**Missing:**
- ❌ No public API documentation
- ❌ No API keys for developers
- ❌ No webhooks for third-party integrations
- ❌ No SDK/client libraries
- ❌ No API rate limiting
- ❌ No API versioning

**Required:**
- OpenAPI/Swagger documentation
- API key generation endpoint
- Webhook configuration UI
- Developer portal

**Impact:** Cannot integrate with external tools. Limited extensibility.

**Effort:** Medium (3-5 days for basic API docs + key management)

---

### 19. **Testing Coverage**

**Status:** No tests exist

**Missing:**
- ❌ No unit tests (frontend or backend)
- ❌ No integration tests
- ❌ No E2E tests
- ❌ No test coverage reports

**Required:**
- Jest + React Testing Library (frontend)
- Jest + Supertest (backend)
- Playwright/Cypress (E2E)
- CI/CD pipeline with test gates

**Impact:** High risk of bugs, difficult to refactor safely.

**Effort:** Ongoing (20-30% of development time)

---

### 20. **Additional E-commerce Platforms**

**Status:** Shopify & WooCommerce partially implemented

**Missing Platforms:**
- ❌ BigCommerce
- ❌ Magento
- ❌ Squarespace
- ❌ Wix
- ❌ PrestaShop
- ❌ Custom/Generic REST API integration

**Required:**
- OAuth flows for each platform
- Product sync adapters
- Order webhook handlers
- Platform-specific configuration

**Impact:** Limited market reach. Many e-commerce users excluded.

**Effort:** Large per platform (4-5 days each)

---

## 📝 **TODO COMMENTS IN CODE**

### Backend (`shopcall.ai-backend-main/api/index.js`)

1. **Line 586:** `// TODO: Save tokenJson.access_token securely`
   - **Context:** Shopify OAuth callback
   - **Issue:** Access tokens not being stored in database
   - **Priority:** 🔴 Critical

2. **Line 604:** `// TODO: Retrieve access token from database`
   - **Context:** Product API endpoint
   - **Issue:** Incomplete API endpoint implementation
   - **Priority:** 🟡 High

3. **Line 677:** `// TODO: Implement your business logic here`
   - **Context:** GDPR webhook processing
   - **Issue:** Webhook processing empty
   - **Priority:** 🟡 High (GDPR compliance issue)

### Frontend
- No TODO comments found in source code

---

## 🎯 **SUMMARY BY PRIORITY**

| Priority | Category | Count | Estimated Effort |
|----------|----------|-------|------------------|
| 🔴 Critical | Core functionality blockers | 4 | 12-15 days |
| 🟡 High | Major features incomplete | 5 | 15-20 days |
| 🟢 Medium | UX and data issues | 6 | 15-20 days |
| 🔵 Low | Enhancement features | 5 | 40-50 days |
| **TOTAL** | | **20** | **82-105 days** |

---

## 💡 **RECOMMENDED DEVELOPMENT ORDER**

### Phase 1: Critical Fixes (2-3 weeks)
1. **Complete Shopify OAuth** - Save tokens, create store records
2. **Connect Integrations UI to backend** - Use existing `/api/stores` endpoints
3. **Implement Phone Number Management APIs** - Critical for service to work
4. **Implement AI Configuration APIs** - Required for customization

### Phase 2: Data & Analytics (2-3 weeks)
5. **Connect Analytics to real data** - Replace mock data with real queries
6. **Connect Dashboard KPIs** - Real-time metrics
7. **Onboarding flow backend integration** - Save user selections
8. **Call recording playback** - Audio player implementation

### Phase 3: User Experience (2-3 weeks)
9. **Add search & filtering** - Improve call log navigation
10. **Export functionality** - CSV/PDF export
11. **User profile management** - Edit profile, change password
12. **Email notifications** - Call summaries, alerts

### Phase 4: Monetization & Growth (3-4 weeks)
13. **Implement payment system** - Stripe integration
14. **Real-time updates** - WebSocket implementation
15. **Complete WooCommerce integration** - Product sync, webhooks
16. **Team collaboration features** - Multi-user support

### Phase 5: Enhancement & Scale (Ongoing)
17. **Advanced call features** - Forwarding, voicemail, scheduling
18. **API documentation** - Public API + webhooks
19. **Additional e-commerce platforms** - BigCommerce, Magento
20. **Testing coverage** - Unit, integration, E2E tests

---

## 🔍 **TECHNICAL DEBT ITEMS**

1. **In-memory state stores** (`pendingSignups`, `nonceStore` Maps in `api/index.js`)
   - ⚠️ Will reset on serverless function cold starts
   - Should use Redis or database

2. **Hardcoded URLs** in frontend
   - Backend URL: `https://shopcall-ai-backend.vercel.app` (should be env variable)
   - Frontend URL: `https://shopcall.ai` (should be env variable)

3. **No database migrations system**
   - Using Supabase migrations manually
   - Should have automated migration tool

4. **No error tracking**
   - No Sentry or error monitoring
   - Console.log only

5. **No API versioning**
   - Breaking changes will break all clients
   - Should implement `/api/v1/...`

6. **No rate limiting**
   - API endpoints not protected
   - Vulnerable to abuse

---

## 📊 **FEATURE COMPLETENESS MATRIX**

| Feature Category | UI Complete | Backend Complete | Integration Complete | Overall |
|-----------------|-------------|------------------|---------------------|---------|
| Authentication | ✅ 100% | ✅ 100% | ✅ 100% | ✅ **100%** |
| Onboarding | ✅ 100% | ❌ 0% | ❌ 0% | ⚠️ **33%** |
| Dashboard | ✅ 100% | ⚠️ 50% | ❌ 30% | ⚠️ **60%** |
| Call Logs | ✅ 100% | ✅ 90% | ✅ 90% | ✅ **93%** |
| Analytics | ✅ 100% | ❌ 0% | ❌ 0% | ⚠️ **33%** |
| Integrations | ✅ 100% | ✅ 80% | ❌ 20% | ⚠️ **67%** |
| Phone Numbers | ✅ 100% | ❌ 0% | ❌ 0% | ⚠️ **33%** |
| AI Config | ✅ 100% | ❌ 0% | ❌ 0% | ⚠️ **33%** |
| User Profile | ❌ 0% | ⚠️ 50% | ❌ 0% | ❌ **17%** |
| Payments | ⚠️ 50% | ❌ 0% | ❌ 0% | ❌ **17%** |
| **OVERALL** | | | | ⚠️ **48%** |

---

## 🚨 **SECURITY & COMPLIANCE CONCERNS**

1. **GDPR Webhooks Not Implemented** (line 677)
   - Shopify GDPR webhooks receive data but don't process it
   - Legal compliance issue

2. **No API Key Encryption**
   - Store API keys/tokens stored in plain text
   - Should use encryption at rest

3. **No Session Management**
   - Tokens in localStorage never expire on frontend
   - No refresh token mechanism

4. **No CORS Configuration Per Environment**
   - CORS enabled globally with `app.use(cors())`
   - Should restrict origins

5. **Email Credentials in Code**
   - Default Gmail credentials in code (lines 36-38)
   - Should be env-only

---

## 📋 **NEXT STEPS**

1. **Prioritize Phase 1** (Critical fixes)
2. **Set up project tracking** (GitHub Projects, Jira, etc.)
3. **Create detailed tickets** for each feature
4. **Establish CI/CD pipeline** with test gates
5. **Set up error monitoring** (Sentry)
6. **Document API** as features are completed
7. **Create staging environment** for testing

---

**Report End** - For questions or clarifications, refer to source code locations provided in each section.
